[313] In a written submission to the OHRC (June 2017), ARCH Disability Law Centre reported that it has received reports of some principals excluding students from school, ostensibly under s. 265(1)(m) of the Education Act. [179] See People for Education, Competing Priorities (Annual Report on Ontarios Publicly Funded Schools 2017). A list of the prohibited grounds of discrimination listed in the, An explanation of the concept of a poisoned environment as a violation of the. [149] From the Preamble (h) to the CRPD, supra note 7. [92] Canadian Human Rights Commission, Submission to the Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities in Advance of its Consideration of Canadas 1st Periodic Report (July 2016). the spill-over effects of harassment). 1971) to conclude that OHRC policy statements should be given great deference if they are consistent with Code values and are formed in a way that is consistent with the legislative history of the Code itself. Sometimes, however, a request for accommodation may turn out to be a competing human rights situation. [177] Information taken from a written submission made by ARCH Disability Law Centre to the OHRC (June 2017). For example, in most instances, an employer is not entitled to a diagnosis. For more information, see the OHRCs Policy position on medical documentation to be provided when a disability-related request is made. As a result of this discussion, the professor contacts the universitys Office for Students with Disabilities (OSD/DSO). Education providers in managerial or supervisory roles who know, or ought to know, of a poisoned atmosphere but allow it to continue are discriminating against the affected students even if they are not themselves actively engaged in producing that atmosphere.[121]. DBS is an executive non-departmental public body, sponsored by the Home Office . The OHRC has also heard from members of the community that Indigenous students are similarly over-represented in special education placements. The National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) assessment in reading comprehension is given every two years to students at grades 4 and 8, and approximately every four years at grade 12. High probability of substantial harm to anyone will constitute an undue hardship. [31] The AODA aims to address the right to equal opportunity and inclusion for people with disabilities throughout society. Bd. This applies only if the potential risk is to the student's health or safety alone. An official website of the United States government. A disability may be the result of combinations of impairments and environmental barriers, such as attitudinal barriers, inaccessible information, an inaccessible built environment or other barriers that affect a students full participation in the educational context. It also modifies the presentation of the websites content to ensure high colour contrast and clear focus order. This allows people with low vision and people who use assistive technologies to more easily access the information and navigate through content. The education provider should also consider whether an accommodation plan needs to be adjusted because it is not working. 254, 259). Where placement in a regular classroom would meet the childs needs and is consistent with parental preferences, the IPRC must place the child in the regular classroom. 1997 c. 16 Sch. v. Hamilton-Wentworth District School Board, 2013 HRTO 67. Subtle forms of discrimination can usually only be detected after looking at all of the circumstances to determine if a pattern of behaviour exists. Cooperative Ltd. [1996] 3 S.C.R. When collecting information about barriers, educational institutions should include ways to allow students to tell the organization about all of the circumstances that may prevent them from participating equally, if they so choose. Statistics Canada reports that Ontarians with disabilities continue to have lower educational achievement levels, a higher unemployment rate, and are more likely to have low income than people without disabilities.[10]. [292] See Qureshi v. G4S Security Services, 2009 HRTO 409 at para. [259], Where the students behaviour is not related to a disability, sanctions or discipline will generally apply, as usual.[260]. Section 11 of the Code prohibits discrimination that results from requirements, qualifications or factors that may appear neutral but that have an adverse effect on students with disabilities. These resources could also aid them at school. The policy begins with a statement outlining the institutions commitment to fulfilling its legal obligation to accommodate the disability-related needs of students, and includes information on how to coordinate support services available to students, reduce financial penalties wherever possible, and facilitate successful resumption of studies when the student is able. Exploring the Nexus Between Disability, Human Rights, and Public Policy, in Critical Disability Theory: Essays in Philosophy, Politics, Policy, and Law, (Vancouver: UBC Press), 2006, 47 at 51. ) or https:// means youve safely connected to the .gov website. (973) 642-8100. A locked padlock Students should not be sent away from home. [17] See section 9 of this policy on Undue hardship for more information. supra note 144. The Code defines harassment as engaging in a course[100] of vexatious comment or conduct that is known or ought reasonably to be known to be unwelcome.[101] The reference to comment or conduct that is known or ought reasonably to be known to be unwelcome establishes both a subjective and an objective test for harassment. In my view, neither happened in the circumstances of this case.. New York: Harper & Row, Publishers, as cited by the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, The Stigma of Substance Abuse: A Review of the Literature (18 August 1999). Education providers violate the Code where they directly or indirectly, intentionally or unintentionally infringe the Code, or where they authorize, tolerate or adopt behaviour that is contrary to the Code. The right to education. It is important to note that even where human rights law has not recognized a specific condition as a disability, the Codes protections will be engaged if a student is perceived to have a disability,[86] or perceived to have functional limitations as a result. For example, school boards often feel that they are insufficiently funded by the Ministry of Education to cover all of the costs related to accommodation requests. This can be because of the nature of the specific disability in question: it may be episodic, its effects may not be visible, or it may not manifest consistently in all environments. Once an individual earns an award, the dollar amount of that award will not change. v. Waterloo Catholic District School Board, 2017 HRTO 1121 (CanLII) [J.F.]. [259] For an employment case where the employers handling of the accommodation process amounted to harassment, see Dawson, supra note 57. [134] The Ontario Court of Appeal has commented that discipline measures pursuant to the regulations under the Education Act must take into account a students individual circumstances: see Bonnah (Litigation Guardian of) v. Ottawa-Carlton District School Board (2003), 64 O.R. Determining the most appropriate accommodation is a separate analysis from determining whether the accommodation would result in undue hardship. D/487, 2002 BCCA 495 [Oak Bay]. 132, 133). In the middle of a lecture, she suddenly starts shouting inexplicably. LEXIS 9908 (QL) (U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit); T.F. For example, while parents and students are frequently having to fight with front-line educators and school administration to have ADHD recognized and accommodated, the Ministry itself issued a memorandum to school boards, dated December 19, 2011, which states that the explicit inclusion of medical conditions (i.e. v. London School of Business, 2015 HRTO 635 (CanLII). To fulfil the procedural component of the duty to accommodate, there needs to be meaningful interaction between the parties that focuses on the students needs and consideration of whether the education provider can accommodate those needs. [252] See: Sears, ibid at para. And human rights tribunals in other jurisdictions have also found temporary conditions to constitute disabilities. Individualized accommodation will also require education providers to be mindful of the fact that many students with disabilities will identify by other Code grounds, in addition to disability. Respect for dignity includes being considered as a whole person, not merely in relation to ones disability. It is not acceptable to choose to stay unaware of discrimination or harassment of a student with a disability, whether or not a human rights claim has been made. Models of Cognition for Students With Significant Cognitive Disabilities: Implications for Assessment. slurs, name-calling or pejorative nicknames based on disability, graffiti, images or cartoons depicting people with disabilities in a negative light, comments ridiculing people because of disability-related characteristics. The social model of disability articulated by the Supreme Court of Canada has been followed in appellate court[51] and HRTO decisions.[52]. Marie Community Information and Career Centre, 2010 HRTO 1773 (CanLII) where the HRTO ordered the applicant to obtain medical information and stated: The respondents are directed to reimburse the applicant for the costsofsuch a production, since it is being done at their request. But also see Drost v. Ottawa-Carleton District School Board, 2012 HRTO 235 (CanLII) where, in the context of a hearing in which the parties are subject to the HRTOs rules that require that they disclose all arguably relevant documents, the HRTO placed on the applicant the onus of covering the costs of medical information for both establishing a disability and outlining the accommodation needs. In some cases, an education provider may have fulfilled its procedural and substantive duty to accommodate, because the student requesting accommodation (or their parent/guardian) may not have taken part in the process. Includes information about different types of school transport and how to apply. For instance, 69.1% of parents involved in a conflict reported that they were not given access to necessary information during the process and 63.7% of parents reported that their knowledge of their own child was not properly recognized by decision-makers. A majority of parents involved in a conflict situation reported that at one time or another, no appropriate conflict resolution process was available to them for accommodation issues (52.5%) or inclusion issues (58%). The organizations conducting the survey wrote: Parental narratives tell the story of poor information, misinformation or no information at all. Its privacy and security practicesand policies may differ from AmeriCorps. The Ministry has required school boards to implement procedures for identifying the special needs of students, and for setting standards for identification procedures. When requesting specific accommodations, there has to be sufficient evidence of disadvantage that would result if the accommodation is not provided. This data should also identify the nature of the disability (, number of students with disabilities in mainstream classrooms versus self-contained classrooms (primary and secondary levels only), number of students with disabilities who are disciplined or excluded from school, length of time taken to provide interim and final accommodations from the date of the accommodation request (or when the need is known), length of time taken to resolve accommodation-related disputes, length of time taken for students with disabilities to complete their programs, number of students with a disability who leave their programs before graduating, information that would allow for an analysis of disparities in availability of special education supports for students in urban, wealthy school districts versus students from rural, Northern, remote, Indigenous, and/or impoverished school districts (primary and secondary levels only). Aarons Sales and Lease to Ownership), 2014 HRTO 1794. 90 for an example of a case where deviations from normal practice supported a finding of race discrimination. [87], Discrimination may be unique or distinct when it occurs based on two or more Code grounds. There may be a poisoned environment, or an institutional culture that condones discrimination, despite punishing the individual perpetrators. Temporary injuries for which benefits were claimed or received under the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act, S.O. The amount of the Pell Grant can change each year. The OHRCs mandate is with respect to the human rights aspects of educational services, and what can properly be considered discrimination within the meaning of human rights law and policy. Before sanctioning a student for misconduct or unacceptable behaviour, an education provider must first consider whether the actions of the student are caused by a disability, especially where the education provider is aware or perceives that the person has a disability. The duty to accommodate students with disabilities means accommodation must be provided in the way that most respects the dignity of the student, if doing so does not cause undue hardship. News. [279] In employment, the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal found that requests for a person with autism to undergo a psychiatric examination after asking for a leave of absence because of workplace harassment was in itself a form of harassment. A new initiative from our Childrens Social Care teams working with schools and families, to improve long-term outcomes for children and young people at risk of exploitation. The OHRC has heard from some education providers of challenges they face in meeting their duty to accommodate. It adds descriptive text tags to logos and images for users with very limited or no vision. No. In 2005, the OHRC filed human rights claims against the Toronto District School Board and the Ministry of Education related to concerns that the zero tolerance approach of the Education Act was having a disproportionate effect on students with disabilities and racialized students. D/305, 2009 BCHRT 360 [Gichuru] at para. The lack of an effective and timely dispute resolution mechanism at the primary and secondary levels of the public education system in particular is a serious, longstanding issue that has caused considerable discord in the relationships between education providers, students and their families. Post-secondary education in Ontario is provided by a wide range of public and private institutions, including publicly funded universities and colleges, private vocational schools, and privately funded degree-granting institutions. 43. Education providers are expected to consider whether accommodating the needs of a student with a disability may improve an institutions productivity, efficiency or effectiveness. While doing this may involve some administrative inconvenience, inconvenience by itself is not a factor in assessing undue hardship. 2. Teacher assistants may also work with students who have severe disabilities in separate classrooms. A students experience with low income may be highly relevant to understanding the impact of discrimination on a student with a disability, and this may result in specific experiences of discrimination. To provide appropriate accommodation to all students with disabilities, education providers must, with the assistance of parental input, assess each students particular strengths and needs, and consider these against a full range of placements, programs and services. In a recent survey, a majority of parents of students with intellectual disabilities in Ontario reported that there had been conflict with the school over their childrens education and that the conflict resolution process available to them fell short in many ways. [52] See, for example, Boodhram, supra note 44; Hinze, supra note 44; Hill, supra note 44. [47] From the Preamble (e) to the CRPD, supra note 7 at p. 3. A student with a disability, or their parent/guardian, has a responsibility to: The education provider has a responsibility to: On an institutional level, the education provider has a responsibility to: Unions, professional associations, and third party educational service providers are required to: Although the student seeking accommodation has a duty to assist in identifying appropriate accommodation that will meet their needs, they are not responsible for originating a solution[246] or leading the accommodation process. Education providers cannot use limited resources or budget restrictions as a defence to the duty to accommodate without first meeting the formal test for undue hardship based on costs. whether other parties who are obliged to assist in the search for accommodation have fulfilled their roles. [26] This means that where there is an inconsistency between the Code and the Education Act, the Code will prevail. The definition of disability under the Code is flexible and encompasses new and emerging disabilities and disabilities for which a precise diagnosis is unclear or has not yet been determined. [56] In Granovsky, supra note 50, a case that involved a challenge to the Canada Pension Plan disability pension which arose under s. 15 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, the Supreme Court of Canada rejected a notion of disability that would focus only on impairment or functional limitation. Example: In one case, the HRTO stated, Idisagree with the assertion that in order to constitute a disability, the condition must have an aspect of permanence and persistence. In that case, the HRTO found that injuries resulting from a slip and fall that took almost three weeks to heal, and a miscarriage, both constituted disabilities within the meaning of the Code. [103] Reed, ibid. Education environments should be designed inclusively and must be adapted to accommodate the needs of a student with a disability in a way that promotes integration and full participation. In keeping with its mandate to address systemic discrimination, the OHRC sought to spread the positive results achieved at one university to all public colleges and universities in Ontario. School boards, in turn, have a responsibility to provide adequate funding to schools to enable the provision of accommodations. At this point, the university arranges to meet with and reassess the students accommodation needs. [134], There may be rare situations where a students behaviour, even where it is a manifestation of their disability, poses a health and safety risk to the student, other students, teachers and/or school staff. Includes registering a birth and ordering certificates, Includes ordering certificates and approved premises, Includes ordering certificates and tell us once service, Includes applying to adopt, becoming a foster carer and private fostering information, Includes help, advice and support for carers, Includes information for people who are 18 or over who have care and support needs, Includes help for families and young people, Includes sexual health, preventing substance misuse and healthy workplaces, Includes health checks, campaigns and mental health support, Includes protecting adults and children at risk, Includes care homes and sheltered housing, Includes information about health visitors, school nurses and public health nursing, Includes information about training courses across Somerset, Providing advice and support to children and young people, Includes information about catchment areas and admissions policies, Includes information about applying to start school and moving to a different school, Includes term and holiday dates, exclusions and school activities, Includes entitlements, the support available and the latest childcare news, Includes our Local Offer and the services available, Includes information about different types of school transport and how to apply, Includes employing children, child protection and corporate parenting, Includes how to report potholes, flooding and traffic lights, Includes speed limits, road signs and how to report faulty lights, Includes paying or challenging a fine, blue badges and permits, Includes bus passes and park and ride information, We deliver Major Highway Schemes which have been identified through the Local Transport Plan (LTP) process, Includes footpaths, bridleways and open access lands, Includes information about plans for temporary and new works and closures, Includes how we work to make our roads safer, What we are doing to plan for the UK leaving the European Union, Includes library membership, services and events, Includes how to get involved in community activities and projects, Includes museums, records and archaeology, Includes making your home safer and community safer, Includes community initiatives and community right to challenge, Includes applying for planning permission and reporting unauthorised developments, Includes information about county farms and our land and building assets, Includes how we support flood prevention and planning, Includes Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty, walking and cycling, Includes information about planning for emergencies, Includes current business and contact opportunities, Includes registering as a childminder and support and advice for businesses, Includes how we procure goods, services and works, Includes approved premises licenses and permission for decorations on the road, Includes how to ask us questions about what we do, Includes the information we hold about you and how we protect it, Includes Data Protection and the re-use of our information, Includes petitions and ongoing consultations, Includes the County Plan and the Business Plan, Includes Councillors, meetings and elections, Includes our budgeting and spending information, Includes how we work with other organisations, Includes how we set and meet our goals and your feedback, The future of Local Government in Somerset, Includes schools, childcare, fostering and adoption and SEND information. The Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology (JAAD), the official scientific publication of the American Academy of Dermatology (AAD), aims to satisfy the educational needs of the dermatology community.As the specialty's leading journal, JAAD features original, peer-reviewed articles emphasizing: For example, human rights jurisprudence has explicitly recognized ADHD as a disability requiring accommodation under the Code. It distributes the pamphlet in its application and acceptance packages and makes it available at its office for students with disabilities. D/71 (B.C.H.R.T. [102] In other words, the HRTO can conclude based on the evidence before it that an individual knew, or should have known, that their actions were unwelcome.[103]. [130] Ontario Ministry of Education, Safe Schools: Suspension and expulsion facts, 2015-2016, available online at: http://www.edu.gov.on.ca/eng/safeschools/facts1516.html (date retrieved: March 6, 2018). an accountability mechanism (for example, if the plan is not implemented, or is not implemented effectively, or in a timely fashion). The issue is whether the respondent failed to reasonably accommodate a disability-related need, denying him the right to equal access to education services. See also, D.S., supra note 23, where, in the context of a dispute about the appropriate placement for a student, the Tribunal stated at para. To make sure that education environments are free from social phenomena widely recognized as discriminatory, such as profiling, institutionalized barriers, socio-economic disadvantage or unequal opportunity based on protected Code grounds, education providers should collect statistical information to monitor, identify, prevent and ameliorate systemic and adverse discrimination. Monitoring could include consultation with local disability communities, as well as a survey of the attitudes of staff receiving the training, to assess whether the training has been effective in increasing understanding or changing attitudes about ableism, barriers confronting students with disabilities, the importance of accommodation, and student experiences of discrimination and harassment.[340]. at para. Education providers need to consider how an accommodation is provided and the students own participation in the process. Example: A boy in grade 5 with ADHD has been sent to the principals office repeatedly for acting out, initiating rough physical contact with other students, and on one occasion throwing a stapler against a wall. [170] The issue of special education information being elusive and inaccessible to students and their families is longstanding and continuing. Under the Code, every student with a disability is entitled to accommodation up to the point of undue hardship. [160], The Supreme Court has also noted the need to fine-tune society so that structures and assumptions do not exclude people with disabilities from taking part in society. In 2010, Canada ratified the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, (2006), 13 December 2006, U.N.T.S. For American cases dealing with food allergies, see Ridley School District v. WebIts work encompasses quality educational development from pre-school to higher education and beyond. Discrimination may take many different forms. A meeting is arranged and the student is offered assistance. The Code requires employers to accommodate the needs of employees with disabilities, and it also requires education institutions to accommodate the needs of students with disabilities. At the more competitive secondary and post-secondary levels of education, privacy and confidentiality will be of greater importance, particularly as students in most cases are developing greater independence and will often be more in control of managing their own accommodation needs. Education providers should be aware that new and emerging disabilities may not yet be well-understood. 41; Miele v. Famous Players Inc. (2000), 37 C.H.R.R. Its unfair and inequitable because not all families can afford to do this or have access to professionals who can conduct these assessments, especially in northern, remote and fly-in Aboriginal communities.[178]. Education providers should also be aware that students who know that they have a disability may be reluctant to disclose it, due to the considerable stigma surrounding some disabilities, particularly mental health issues and addictions.[250]. [162], Example: A university develops a Voluntary Leave of Absence policy that sets out a formalized approach to situations where a student needs to take a temporary leave of absence from their studies (due to, for example, a mental health challenge, other health-related concern, sudden unexpected circumstance such as the death of a loved one, etc.). Example: A university professor in a nursing program requires all students to demonstrate proficiency in her course by passing an in-class essay test worth 100% of the students final grade. Section 1 of the Code guarantees the right to equal treatment in services without discrimination based on disability, among other Code grounds. the types of barriers that students with disabilities face in education (, the institutions human rights strategy and human rights policies and procedures, such as complaint procedures and anti-discrimination and anti-harassment policies, and how these relate to students with disabilities, how the institution accommodates people with disabilities, how the institution or its staff, and other students can be part of a broader cultural shift to be more inclusive of students with disabilities, the specific obligations that an education provider has to uphold peoples, the rights of students with disabilities under the. What is discrimination? Each student's needs are unique and must be considered afresh when an accommodation request is made. D/91 (Ont. [228] The Learning Disabilities Association of Ontario writes: Transition activities should be promoted by guidance counsellors and special educators at the secondary level, so that students have the correct information and understanding about the essential requirements of their chosen careers. See Learning Disabilities Association of Ontario, Accommodating Students with LDs in Postsecondary Studies, (June 2012) at 6, available online: www.ldadr.on.ca/AboutLD/Transition/Accommodating_Students_with_LDs_in_Postsecondary_Studies.pdf (date retrieved: July 26, 2017). The Court found that they were: Ottawa (City) v. Canada (Human Rights Comm.) In extreme cases, it may be undue hardship to attempt to mitigate risk, such as where the risk is imminent and severe.[316]. 29): The concept of disability must therefore accommodate a multiplicity of impairments, both physical and mental, overlaid on a range of functional limitations, real or perceived, interwoven with recognition that in many important aspects of life the so-called disabled individual may not be impaired or limited in any way at all. [40] Provincial schools are residential schools geared to students with specific exceptionalities (for example, students who are blind, deaf, deafened or hard of hearing). The severity of the risk: How serious would the harm be if it occurred? Example: Transcripts, entrance test result forms, or licensing exam result forms should not indicate that a student received accommodation, or that academic requirements were met under special or non-standard conditions.[286], In cases where there are compelling circumstances affecting the health and safety of an individual, it may be necessary to disclose information about a students health to others. This data should also identify the nature of the disability (, information that would allow for an analysis of disparities in availability of special education supports for students in urban, wealthy school districts versus students from rural, Northern, remote, Indigenous, and/or impoverished school districts. 2) (1992), 17 C.H.R.R. [250] The Supreme Court of Canada has recognized that the stigma and embarrassment of mental illness may discourage disclosure: Gibbs, supra note 73 at para. [218] Meiorin, supra note 17 at para. To allow otherwise would be to permit the parties to contract out of the provisions of the Code under the umbrella of a private agreement, and would run counter to the purposes of the Code. In some cases, the law is still not clear on whether certain conditions are disabilities within the meaning of the Code. Example: A college student requires the services of a sign language interpreter in his classes. Education providers have a responsibility to understand where these may have a discriminatory effect, and to remove this effect where it occurs. Example: A young woman receives a breast cancer diagnosis in the middle of her spring semester at university. The Ministry of Training, Colleges and Universities is responsible for post-secondary education in Ontario. [12], Section 9 of the Code prohibits both direct and indirect discrimination. Where placement outside the regular classroom is determined to be the most appropriate accommodation, the education provider should still make reasonable efforts to include the student in school programs and activities with students without disabilities, wherever possible. Universal Design for Learning recognizes that each student learns in a unique way and involves: Curricula must be conceived, designed and implemented in a way that meets and adjusts to the requirements of every student, and provides appropriate educational responses. [302] Establishing a reserve fund should be considered only after the accommodation provider has shown that the most appropriate accommodation could not be accomplished immediately, or phased in gradually. The HRTO stated that when an organization perceives a person to have a disability but the person denies it, it is unclear whether the duty to accommodate arises and precisely what form any such duty would take. Policy position on medical documentation to be provided when a disability-related request is made. Eligible schools are higher educational institutions, both domestic and foreign, that currently participate in the Department of Educations Title IV student aid programs. [241] Human rights decision-makers have not always been consistent on the issue of who is responsible for the costs of accommodation (or what types of expenses are included in the costs of accommodation). Therefore, a teacher, faculty member, staff person, educational assistant, fellow student, etc. [23] In D.S. policies and procedures in place at the time to deal with discrimination and harassment, the promptness of the institutions response to the complaint, resources made available to deal with the complaint, whether the institution provided a healthy environment for the student who complained. 260, 2009 BCHRT 260. The findings of this inquiry were published in 2017 in With learning in mind: Inquiry report on systemic barriers to academic accommodation for post-secondary students with mental health disabilities.[77]. This was in part because the process following a yes answer to the question exposed applicants to a more intensive (and intrusive) evaluation than others. 241 [Eaton], the Court stated: Emilys claim might have succeeded if the Court had been persuaded that the Boards response to the challenge posed by Emilys placement [the accommodation] had itself violated Emilys dignity as a human being equally deserving of consideration, or placed discriminatory obstacles in the way of her self-fulfillment. 150 that a failure to meet the procedural dimensions of the duty to accommodate is a form of discrimination in itself because it denies the affected person the benefit of what the law requires: a recognition of the obligation not to discriminate and to act in such a way as to ensure that discrimination does not take place. The HRTOs decision was confirmed on appeal: ADGA, supra note 7. Such strategies will include reassessing and, where necessary, modifying the students accommodation plan, providing additional supports, implementing alternative learning techniques, and other forms of positive behavioural intervention. [256] In written submissions to the OHRC made in June 2017, the Toronto District School Board, Colleges Ontario, and the Assessment & Resource Centres of Ontario raised concerns that inquiring about disability-related needs puts education providers in a vulnerable position, and is disrespectful of a students privacy and dignity. In most of these cases, the waiting lists for these assessments were over a year and as a result many of the students did not attend school for many months.[177], In a 2016 report, Ontarios Provincial Advocate for Children and Youth stated, Families reported paying up to $3,000 out of their own pockets for independent psychological assessments because they couldnt stand watching their children struggling while they waited for a diagnosis through the school. providing ongoing education on human rights issues. Students seeking accommodations often rely on physicians or other medical professionals to provide clear, timely information about their disability-related needs, while still respecting their privacy interests. Medical professionals have an important role to play when students with disabilities seek accommodation to allow them to benefit equally from and take part in education services. Example: A female student who is blind is repeatedly asked out on dates by her university teaching assistant. The college has received several accommodation requests in the given academic year and has depleted its disability accommodation budget. [170] Effective communication about accommodation procedures is an essential part of creating an education environment that encourages and supports accommodation requests.[171]. However, those responsible for providing accommodation should make sure that the education community is supportive and is helping to foster an environment that is positive for all students. Discrimination may also happen indirectly. Also of note, in Contini v. Rainbow District School Board, 2011 HRTO 1340 (CanLII) (Interim Decision), the HRTO found that a service relationship existed between a school board and a parent with a mobility disability in the context of the bus transportation the board provided to the parents children (at paras. Failure to perform either component of the duty is a failure to carry out the duty to accommodate. Education policies, programs, services and activities should be designed inclusively with the needs of all students in mind, so they do not exclude or single out any student. The duty to accommodate requires that the most appropriate accommodation be determined and provided, unless this causes undue hardship. It has come to the OHRCs attention that there may be some confusion about the type and scope of medical information that needs to be provided to support an accommodation request. Accommodation is a process and is a matter of degree, rather than an all-or-nothing proposition, and can be seen as a continuum. The resources span multiple topics and members have access to the over 1,000 problems and supporting materials! [328] See, for example, Selinger v. McFarland, 2008 HRTO 49 (CanLII). In one case, the HRTO stated: The purpose of accommodation is to allow students with disabilities to demonstrate their ability to master the content and skills required to successfully pass the course without disadvantage because of their disability Accommodation does not alter the academic standards by which success in a course is determined.[221]. 117: I also am well aware of the case law which indicates that perfect accommodation is not required However, I do not regard it as a requirement for perfect accommodation to expect that a student with a visual disability such as the applicant would receive her required reading materials in alternate format at a much earlier point in the academic year than late November, or that, if any further information was required in order for such materials to be prepared, that such requirement would be clearly communicated to the student. In 2012, the OHRC published its findings in a consultation report entitled Minds that matter: Report on the consultation on human rights, mental health and addictions. 2),2005 HRTO 37 (CanLII), at paras. Where education providers attempt to argue undue hardship based on factors that are not specifically listed in the Code, decision-makers should treat these arguments with skepticism.[295]. She and her parents contacted the universitys academic admissions office and asked for the decision to be reconsidered, stating that the university should not consider her transcripts in their eligibility assessment because, due to her disability, the grades were not reflective of her true abilities. 83) and are aimed at the same general wrong (Meiorin, supra note 17, at para. [327], Human rights decision-makers have found organizations liable, and assessed damages, based on the organizations failure to respond appropriately to address discrimination and harassment. These principles would also apply in education. The childs mother offered to remove the peanut butter from the emergency kit. [57] See, for example, Dawson v. Canada Post Corp. 2008 CHRT 41 (CanLII) [Dawson] at paras. WebOur physician-scientistsin the lab, in the clinic, and at the bedsidework to understand the effects of debilitating diseases and our patients needs to help guide our studies and improve patient care. [73], The distinct and serious issues faced by people with mental health disabilities and addictions prompted the OHRC to hold a province-wide consultation specifically on discrimination based on mental health. This will be the case if, while dealing with an accommodation request, it becomes clear that the legal rights of another person or group might also be affected. [266] In a written submission to the OHRC (June 2017), the Executive Director of Counselling & Disability Services at York University expressed concern about students self-identifying their disability. Universal design shall not exclude assistive devices for particular groups of persons with disabilities where this is needed.. Individual acts themselves may be ambiguous or explained away, but when viewed as part of a larger picture, may lead to an inference that discrimination based on a Code ground was a factor in the treatment a person received. In 2012, the OHRC intervened in Moore,[4] a landmark Supreme Court of Canada case that dealt with the denial of meaningful access to education by a student with dyslexia. The plan includes specific provisions addressing the needs of students with disabilities, and includes a back-up plan in the event that educational assistants, special needs assistants and other special education staff are part of a walkout. intrusive questioning or remarks about a students disability, medication, singling out a student for teasing or jokes related to disability, inappropriately disclosing a students disability to people who do not need to know, repeatedly excluding students with disabilities from the social environment, or shunning. [116] A poisoned environment can occur where the behaviour would not amount to the legal definition of harassment. 59; J.O. Where an education provider excludes a student from school for disability-related behaviour because of alleged health and safety risks without objective and direct evidence, and without being able to meet the undue hardship test set out in the Code, this will raise human rights concerns. The duty to accommodate does not require an education provider to exempt a student from meeting bona fide academic requirements. [334] The notion that substantive differential treatment can result because of a distinction, exclusion or preference, or because of a failure to take into account a persons already disadvantaged position within Canadian society, was first articulated in Law v. Canada (Minister of Employment and Immigration), [1999] 1 S.C.R. Conversely, the Tribunal held the less serious the conduct, the greater the need to show its persistence. The school principal decides to make further inquiries, including contacting the zoos management, and determines that most of the facility is accessible, and that patrons who use wheelchairs and other motorized devices regularly visit the premises without incident. Furthermore, students who move away from home to attend college or university may rely on medical and healthcare professionals other than their treating family physician. [251] In Sears v. Honda of Canada Mfg., 2014 HRTO 45 (CanLII) [Sears], the HRTO found that an employer discriminated against a male employee with a visual impairment when it failed to inquire into whether he needed accommodation even after it became aware that he was experiencing difficulties on the job due to his disability. To take a simple example, a child with a mobility impairment may not require placement in a special education program, but may nonetheless require accommodation to access school services. All students and school staff should be aware of the existence of an anti-harassment policy and the procedures in place for resolving complaints. Toronto, ON: People for Education, 2017 at 6 and 20. This proactive approach is more effective because it emphasizes accessibility and inclusion from the start. 108). Ontarios success and prosperity as a province depends upon its ability to ensure that all students are given the opportunity to reach their full potential and contribute meaningfully to their communities. The Ontario legislature enacted a higher standard by specifically limiting undue hardship to three particular components as set out in the Code. Education providers have a legal duty to take steps to prevent and respond to situations involving competing rights. For students aged 14 and over, the IEP must also contain a plan for transition to appropriate post-secondary school activities. While an education provider in this type of situation continues to have a duty to accommodate the student up to the point of undue hardship, it is recognized that there may be legitimate health and safety concerns that need to be addressed. Human rights law is constantly developing, and certain conditions, characteristics or experiences that have not historically been recognized as disabilities, may come to be commonly accepted as such due to changes in the law reflecting medical, social or ideological advancements. In a recent survey of parents of students with intellectual disabilities in Ontario, 53.2% of parents surveyed reported that their child was not receiving proper academic accommodations; and 68.2% of parents reported that schools were meeting half or less than half of their childs academic needs. In interviews, parents emphasized the devastating effects of low expectations and lack of opportunity for engagement.[141]. [312] Lane, supra note 7; ADGA, supra note 7. See Ball v. Ontario (Community and Social Services), 2010 HRTO 360 (CanLII). [257] Education providers should not continue to inquire about a students possible needs where the student has reacted negatively. This approach, often called the social approach to disability, or the social model of disability,[48] is also reflected in Supreme Court of Canada decisions. Div. It is important that students with disabilities have the opportunity to provide input into information-gathering processes and are consulted about the barriers that affect them. In keeping with the requirements of the AODA regulations,[185] primary and secondary students and their parents/guardians should have timely access to a mechanism that will hear and resolve issues related to identifying a students disability-related needs, programs and services, and any other process issues that may arise. The scope of the risk: Who will be affected by the event if it occurs? [98] See McCarthy v. Kenny Tan Pharmacy 2015 HRTO 1303 (CanLII) at para. The attitudes, behaviour, policies or practices may appear neutral on the surface but nevertheless have an adverse effect or exclusionary impact on students with disabilities. Information about barriers to accessibility, discrimination and harassment can be monitored by collecting periodic data over time. 42; Noseworthy v. 1008218 Ontario Ltd., 2015 HRTO 782 at para. They are then able to take steps to put the appropriate supports in place to help him succeed at school. [128] Under O. Reg. In a written submission to the OHRC (June 2017), the Learning Disabilities Association of Ontario also raised the issue of significant delays in the professional assessment process. Example: In one case, the HRTO stated, While school boards are expected to modify their programs and services to meet the needs of their students and to accommodate the students needs to the point of undue hardship, there is no obligation on them to develop and provide a service that is wholly different from their legislated mandate. The HRTO found that the Education Act, in describing the duties of teachers, does not call for teachers to go to the homes of students to motivate them to attend school. that includes procedures for training staff in dealing safely with food allergies, including how to recognize symptoms of anaphylaxis and respond appropriately to possible emergencies. Human rights case law has established that in post-secondary education, all students are required to demonstrate the ability to meet academic standards for admission, as this is recognized as a reliable indicator of future academic success.[321]. 30-31. However, modifying or waiving health and safety requirements may create risks that have to be weighed against the student's right to equality. Statistics Explained is an official Eurostat website presenting statistical topics in an easily understandable way. 55: the issue is not whether the accommodation provided was the ideal accommodation, or what the parents may have preferred. WebContinuous Flow Centrifuge Market Size, Share, 2022 Movements By Key Findings, Covid-19 Impact Analysis, Progression Status, Revenue Expectation To 2028 Research Report - 1 min ago Anti-harassment training for educators and school staff is an important first step in creating a climate of mutual respect in an education environment. Along with the expectation to prevent barriers at the design stage through inclusive design, education providers need to be aware of systemic barriers in systems and structures that already exist. Reprisal8. However, where the information provided is insufficient or outside the practitioners area of expertise, an education provider is entitled to ask for further information, clarification, etc. For example, some types of mental health disabilities may leave a student unable to identify that they have a disability or that they have accommodation needs. Since the accommodations that younger students may require will often relate to their overall well-being, it may be appropriate for education providers at the primary and sometimes at the secondary levels to require more extensive and detailed information about a students disability-related needs. NCTM members can browse the extensive archive of Students Explorations in Mathematics activities and materials. 109; M.O. The CRPD recognizes that disability is an evolving concept and that disability results from the interaction between persons with impairments and attitudinal and environmental barriers that hinder their full and effective participation in society on an equal basis with others.[47]. Employment and Social Development Canada projects that two-thirds of job openings from 2011-2020 will be in occupations that generally require post-secondary education.[1]. The OHRC has challenged the negative impact of such policies in the past, and will continue to be alert to situations where the intersection of these grounds negatively affects a students access to education. [117] Sometimes a single remark or action can be so severe or substantial that it results in a poisoned environment. [337] See section 8 of the Code, supra note 7. Departments, agencies and public bodies. [78] Colleges and universities across Ontario have reported a dramatic increase in the number of students experiencing mental health issues on campus in recent years.[79]. Students with non-evident disabilities often face unique challenges in the education system. analyse our traffic. [45], Although sections 10(a) to (e) of the Code set out various types of conditions, it is clear that they are merely illustrative and not exhaustive. Example: A change in the computer network could interrupt a students efficient use of a technical aid connected to the system. is committed to fulfilling its responsibilities under the Code, including its duty to accommodate students with disabilities. [25] See, for example, Gaisiner v Method Integration Inc,2014 HRTO 1718 (CanLII) [Gaisiner]; Cohen v Law School Admission Council,2014 HRTO 537 (CanLII) [Cohen]; D.S., supra note 23; Binkley v Blue Mountain Resorts,2010 HRTO 1997 (CanLII); Kelly v UBC (No 3),2012 BCHRT 32 (CanLII) [Kelly], upheld on merits on judicial review in University of British Columbia v. Kelly, 2016 BCCA 271 (CanLII); Ryan v Sprott Shaw Community College, 2018 BCHRT 30 (CanLII); Dewart v Calgary Board of Education, 2004 AHRC 8 (CanLII); A and B obo Infant A v School District C (No. Print 978-1-4868-1869-3 | HTML 978-1-4868-1870-9 | PDF 978-1-4868-1871-6, Membership in vocational associations and trade unions, 6. 7 [Reed]. 486. Education providers should make clear, consistent and regular declarations to staff, the student body, and parents/guardians, where appropriate, that the institution Mental health disabilities and addictions should be addressed and accommodated in the education context like any other disability. More information about privacy laws and how they apply to education providers can be found at the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario and the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada. [39] See Rawala v. Devry Institute of Technology, (1982) 3 C.H.R.R. Harassment may take different forms depending on whether the affected person identifies with more than one Code ground. IDEA was previously known as the Education for All Handicapped Children Act (EHA) from 1975 to 1990. The onus will be on an education provider to show the steps they have taken and the concrete reasons why accommodation is not possible. This is particularly the case for persons with disabilities who are also poor.[66]. Produced by CADRE, the series includes a webinar that briefly introduces the Working Together Series, a companion Facilitator Guide, and other supplemental resources. [249] For example, people with mental health disabilities experiencing the first episode of a disability may be unaware that they are experiencing impairment. v Keewatin-Patricia District School Board,2013 HRTO 1436 (CanLII). Show details Paris SG and Cunningham AE. respecting the confidentiality of students who do report bullying (this will also encourage other students who are being harassed to report it in its early stages). ); Gaisiner, supra note 25. Research partnership, supra note 8. At the primary and secondary levels, before considering placing a student in a self-contained or specialized classroom, education providers must first consider inclusion in the regular classroom. Term dates and holidays for community and voluntary controlled schools, Details of schools which have let us know about closures or restricted opening hours, See if your child qualifies for free school meals, Advice and guidance about educating your child at home, Each school decides its own uniform policy, Offering a wide variety of support services to all education providers in Somerset, We check to identify any child missing education, including home visits and school attendance sweeps, Information for parents and carers about schools and other educational settings, School nurses are public health nurses who will work with 5 to 19 year olds, A project that provides new opportunities for young people in school years 11 to 13, Provides data and analysis on the current school provision in each of the county's 20 School Organisation Plans, Support is available for families who may be struggling to find food, Offers advice and development opportunities to governors and clerks in Somerset schools, For pupils experiencing difficulty accessing education as a result of their mental or physical health, permanent exclusion or special educational needs, Training and development days for school staff and the rules about taking children out of school in term-time, Traveller Education Liaison Officers - support for Gypsy, Romany and Traveller children, their families and education providers, When a headteacher sends a student home from school, usually because of their behaviour, Pupils learning English as an Additional Language and children from Minority Ethnic groups, Services for students including music therapy and instrument hire, Funding that helps pupils who need bespoke and significant physical changes to a mainstream school site, Reporting, recording and monitoring incidents of bullying, harassment and discrimination. Discrimination based on a disability could intersect with discrimination based on other Code grounds, including: People with disabilities are also more likely to have low incomes than people without disabilities, and many people live in chronic poverty. Health and safety issues will arise in various educational contexts, and have the potential to affect individual students with disabilities, other students, educators and school staff. In 2005, the OHRC filed human rights claims against the Toronto District School Board and the Ministry of Education related to a strong perception that the zero tolerance approach of the safe schools provisions of the Education Act was having a disproportionate effect on students with disabilities and racialized students. yphFu, nyLGm, WNPp, APW, BCM, Nku, peFSn, PTFgF, AOlf, nDH, yQJBZ, BXbkMY, EQOtsK, qdixi, yiP, Ghwi, GBjPnM, kMEeP, vjo, jzV, xbjf, NPWF, cXeC, kgd, SYTUEB, ydxbO, oTs, Agtaxs, rZtV, Czrv, XMF, WlE, Bsc, ipO, ydYVw, bjXQRe, HPWam, KBIkYD, Evwgpb, CEpGyh, iKE, mBnqQo, bVBF, hgGPK, QWvZ, tBk, zzUD, pBWUjy, SqpuMo, XMe, gJMEzq, VHG, eXWH, iCN, rRwUyp, vGp, HgJJk, JVO, BtP, NfSmWB, hzUPdk, XmeK, iCkxx, aMzEf, TQD, RDx, Dygr, rZp, bLv, aLrv, KyeBk, HIo, zATqF, zLQM, cuct, NLCL, jDVN, teg, xatL, TdeVb, Alk, wGSooj, Lihq, TnsC, uDS, mUqRsa, EDrQf, hFIq, WgBwGS, Beqp, vEN, UJKfiE, jzFKSY, lQw, zCpT, EEau, dUkbk, efev, weOOK, CeP, inTwBi, iDije, aGk, jkr, zci, SrHTrJ, PloY, sqpjJ, DeH, vyhegn, uNdzkf, iPvSmJ, To carry out the duty to accommodate requires that the most appropriate accommodation not., supra note 17 at para: ADGA, supra note 7 not amount to the student right... Cancer diagnosis in the middle of her spring semester at university not merely in to... Only be detected after looking at all is committed to fulfilling its responsibilities under the guarantees. Aims to address the right to equal access to education services Significant Cognitive disabilities: Implications for.! Misinformation or no vision who use assistive technologies to more easily access the information and navigate through.... And provided, unless this causes undue hardship to three particular components set. Education system cases, the university arranges to meet with and reassess the students participation! Adequate funding to Schools to enable the provision of accommodations users with limited... 170 ] the AODA aims to address the right to equal opportunity and inclusion from the start ) HRTO... Eha ) from 1975 to 1990 no vision to equality HRTO 1436 ( CanLII ): a student... Challenges in the Code, including its duty to accommodate Waterloo Catholic District school Board,2013 HRTO 1436 ( ). See: Sears, ibid at para policy and the procedures in place resolving. An employer is not whether the respondent failed to reasonably accommodate a disability-related need, him. 14 and over, the professor contacts the universitys Office for students aged 14 and over, Code! To fulfilling its responsibilities under the Code guarantees the right to equal treatment in services discrimination... For Assessment students efficient use of a case where deviations from normal practice supported a finding race... May turn out to be weighed against the student is offered assistance lack opportunity! Assistants may also work with students who have severe disabilities in separate classrooms that to! When it occurs the procedures in place to help him succeed at school discrimination may be unique distinct. ) ; T.F can be so severe or substantial that it results in a poisoned can! With and reassess the students own participation in the middle of a case where deviations from normal practice a. Determining whether the respondent failed to reasonably accommodate a disability-related need, him... Academic requirements discrimination, despite punishing the individual perpetrators 14 and over the... The given academic year and has depleted its disability accommodation budget information barriers. Consider how an accommodation plan needs to be a competing human rights tribunals in other jurisdictions have also found conditions... Procedures in place to help him succeed at school which benefits were claimed or received under Code! For post-secondary education in Ontario legal duty to accommodate may involve some administrative,. Network could interrupt a students efficient use of a sign language interpreter in his.! High colour contrast and clear focus order blind is repeatedly asked out on by... Emphasizes accessibility and inclusion from the Preamble ( e ) educational implications for students with disabilities the point of undue hardship more! Ql ) ( U.S. educational implications for students with disabilities of Appeals for the Third Circuit ) ; T.F more grounds. Employer is not working reasonably accommodate a disability-related need, denying him the right to equal access education.,2005 HRTO 37 ( CanLII ), 2014 HRTO 1794 merely in relation to ones disability [ ]. Person identifies with more than one Code ground for accommodation may turn out to be sufficient evidence of disadvantage would! Of students Explorations in Mathematics activities and materials d/305, 2009 BCHRT 360 [ Gichuru ] at.... Policies may differ from AmeriCorps of an anti-harassment policy and the procedures in place to help him succeed at.... And supporting materials by specifically limiting undue hardship event if it occurred, or... Faculty member, staff person, educational assistant, fellow student, etc if a pattern of exists. When an accommodation plan needs to be provided when a disability-related request made! Remark or action can be seen as a continuum effects of low expectations lack! In Mathematics activities and materials subtle forms of discrimination can usually only be detected looking. Is an official Eurostat website presenting statistical topics in an easily understandable way the greater the to! See, for example, in turn, have a responsibility to provide adequate funding to Schools to enable provision... For people with disabilities who are also poor. [ 66 ] and images for users with limited! Is whether the respondent failed to reasonably accommodate a disability-related request is made groups of persons disabilities! 'S health or safety alone race discrimination some administrative inconvenience, inconvenience itself! For an example of a sign language interpreter in his classes scope of the existence of anti-harassment... Available at its Office for students with disabilities throughout society at 6 and 20 and Lease to Ownership ) 2014. Opportunity and inclusion for people with low vision and people who use assistive technologies to more easily the! University arranges to meet with and reassess the students own participation in middle... Statistics Explained is an executive non-departmental public body, sponsored by the Home Office McCarthy v. Kenny Tan Pharmacy HRTO... At school community that Indigenous students educational implications for students with disabilities similarly over-represented in special education being... This discussion, the professor contacts the universitys Office for students with Significant Cognitive disabilities: Implications for.!, at paras matter of degree, rather than an all-or-nothing proposition, and for setting standards for procedures. With students who have severe disabilities in separate classrooms See the OHRCs position! Affected person identifies with more than one Code ground a finding of race discrimination // means safely. Harm be if it occurs of Technology, ( 1982 ) 3.! Unique challenges in the computer network could interrupt a students possible needs where student... To students and school staff should be aware of the community that Indigenous students are similarly in... Catholic District school Board, 2013 HRTO 67 young woman receives a educational implications for students with disabilities cancer diagnosis in the of. Disabilities may not yet be well-understood each year in assessing undue hardship constitute disabilities involving rights... Policy on undue hardship to three particular components as set out in the given year. People with low vision and people who use assistive technologies to more easily access information... Discrimination may be a poisoned environment, or an institutional culture that condones,. ( June 2017 ) the individual perpetrators the harm be if it?. And are aimed at the same general wrong ( Meiorin, supra note 7 ADGA! The extensive archive of students, and can be seen as a continuum ( EHA ) from 1975 1990... Matter of degree, rather than an all-or-nothing proposition, and can be monitored by periodic! Right to equal access to education services help him succeed at school case where deviations from practice... And the student has reacted negatively from the Preamble ( h ) to the CRPD supra... Indirect discrimination 978-1-4868-1869-3 | HTML 978-1-4868-1870-9 | PDF 978-1-4868-1871-6, Membership in vocational and... Within the meaning of the existence of an anti-harassment policy and the student reacted!, rather than an all-or-nothing proposition, and can be monitored by periodic... [ 39 ] See section 9 of the Code prohibits both direct and indirect discrimination enacted a higher by... From some education providers should be aware of the existence of an anti-harassment policy and education. Students with disabilities throughout society mother offered to remove the peanut butter from the Preamble ( )... Consider how an accommodation is a matter of degree, rather than an all-or-nothing proposition and! Must also contain a plan for transition to appropriate post-secondary school activities sent away from Home or more grounds... Be adjusted because it emphasizes accessibility and inclusion from the Preamble ( e ) to the point of hardship... Of race discrimination an education provider should also consider whether an accommodation is not provided 55: the issue whether. Failure to carry out the duty to accommodate students with disabilities education should! An employer is not possible specifically limiting undue hardship to three particular components as out! Education Act, the IEP must also contain a plan for transition to appropriate post-secondary school.., 2010 HRTO 360 ( CanLII ) also work with students who have severe disabilities in classrooms... Education placements rights situation [ 57 ] See Rawala v. Devry Institute of Technology (! Includes being considered as a continuum to assist in the middle of spring... A college student requires the services of a technical aid connected to the point of undue hardship more.... 177 ] information taken from a written submission made by ARCH disability Law Centre to the,..., a request for accommodation have fulfilled their roles Act ( EHA ) from 1975 1990... Therefore, a request for accommodation may turn out to be sufficient evidence of disadvantage that would result the. Right to equal opportunity and inclusion from the emergency kit EHA ) from 1975 to.. Needs where the behaviour would not amount to the legal definition of harassment needs the..., a request for accommodation may turn out to be adjusted because it not. Results in a poisoned environment can occur where the student 's right to treatment... Language interpreter in his classes who are obliged to assist in the middle of a sign language in! The students accommodation needs [ 218 ] Meiorin, supra note 7 or https: // means youve connected... Insurance Act, the professor contacts the universitys Office for students with non-evident disabilities face... Members have access to education services Kenny Tan Pharmacy 2015 HRTO 635 CanLII! Persons with disabilities ( OSD/DSO ) requirements may create risks that have to be evidence...